Smile.io vs LoyaltyLion (2026): Loyalty App Pricing and Which to Pick
Smile.io vs LoyaltyLion in 2026: at 1,000 orders a month Smile costs $79 and LoyaltyLion Classic $249. Monthly bills from 200 to 7,500 orders, read November 2026.

Smile.io is the better value for most Shopify stores: at 1,000 orders a month its Standard plan costs $79, while LoyaltyLion's Classic plan costs $249 at the same volume. Smile stays cheaper at every order count where both vendors print a price, and its $199 Growth plan includes VIP tiers that LoyaltyLion sells as an add-on on Classic. LoyaltyLion earns its premium with setup done for you. Prices read on both vendors' pages on November 4, 2026.
That gap matters most to smaller stores, where every fixed monthly fee weighs on margin. A merchant who wants points, referrals and a loyalty page for the least money should start on Smile. A brand that wants the program built and tuned by the vendor's team, in many languages, can justify LoyaltyLion.
Toolradar data: in the 25-tool referral marketing category on Toolradar, the software directory we run, Smile.io is listed as an alternative to 20 other tools (#1 of 25) and LoyaltyLion to 12 (#2 of 25), as of November 2026. They are the two most cross-shopped tools in that category, so a store owner comparing loyalty apps usually ends up weighing exactly these two.
Smile.io vs LoyaltyLion at a glance
Figures below come from Smile.io's pricing page and LoyaltyLion's pricing page, including the order-volume price list LoyaltyLion's plan selector runs on, read on November 4, 2026. Smile bills in US dollars wherever the store is based.
| Smile.io | LoyaltyLion | |
|---|---|---|
| How it prices | Fixed plans with a monthly order allowance | By average monthly order volume |
| Free option | Free plan up to 200 orders a month | Free plan recommended up to 400 orders, per its pricing FAQ |
| Cheapest paid plan | Essential, $15/mo for 500 orders | Classic, $199/mo for 500 orders |
| At 1,000 orders a month | Standard, $79/mo | Classic, $249/mo |
| First plan with VIP tiers included | Growth, $199/mo for 2,500 orders | Advanced, custom price |
| Orders over the allowance | $20 per 100 on Growth, $5 per 100 on Plus; none on lower plans | Move up to the price for your volume |
| Top published price | Plus, $999/mo on annual billing for 7,500 orders | Classic, $549/mo at 4,000 orders |
How much does each cost at your order volume?
The table below prices one month at common store sizes, from each vendor's printed plans and LoyaltyLion's own volume price list. Totals are our arithmetic. Smile counts every order placed in the calendar month, and its FAQ says that includes unpaid and refunded orders.
| Monthly orders | Smile.io | LoyaltyLion |
|---|---|---|
| 200 | Free | Free plan (400 orders or fewer) |
| 500 | Essential, $15 | Classic, $199 |
| 1,000 | Standard, $79 | Classic, $249 |
| 1,500 | Growth, $199 | Classic, $299 |
| 2,500 | Growth, $199 | Classic, $399 |
| 4,000 | Growth with 1,500 extra orders, $499 | Classic, $549 |
| 5,000 | Growth with 2,500 extra orders, $699 | Custom quote |
| 7,500 | Plus, $999 on annual billing | Custom quote |
At 1,000 orders a month, Smile costs $948 a year against $2,988 for LoyaltyLion Classic, a $2,040 gap for the same order volume (our arithmetic). The gap narrows as stores grow, because Smile's Growth plan charges $20 for every 100 orders above its allowance while LoyaltyLion's Classic price rises $50 for every 500 orders.
Above 4,000 orders, LoyaltyLion stops printing prices and every plan becomes a quote. Smile keeps a printed path: Growth plus overage reaches the Plus price at 6,500 orders, so a store between 6,500 and 7,500 orders pays no more on Plus, which includes 7,500 orders, provided it accepts annual billing.
Where the order caps bite on Smile
Smile's three small plans have no overage option. Free stops at 200 orders, Essential at 500 and Standard at 1,000, and the pricing table lists no additional order rate for any of them. A store that grows from 1,000 to 1,100 orders a month jumps from Standard to Growth, a $120 monthly step for 100 extra orders.
That cliff is the main cost risk on Smile, and it lands on exactly the stores Smile serves best. If your volume swings around a cap, budget for the next tier rather than the one you sit on in a slow month. Smile's FAQ adds that higher plans offer extra monthly orders at a low cost, which is the Growth and Plus overage above.
LoyaltyLion handles growth more smoothly on paper. Its FAQ says a store that exceeds its plan's limit can upgrade to a tier that fits its volume, and the Classic price list moves in $50 steps every 500 orders up to 4,000, so there is no single jump as steep as Smile's.
When do VIP tiers start?
VIP tiers, where your best customers earn better rewards, are where the two pricing ladders diverge most. Smile includes VIP tiers from its Growth plan at $199 a month, along with the Loyalty Hub for signed-in members, redeeming points at checkout and performance benchmarks.
LoyaltyLion lists VIP tiers as an optional add-on on Classic and includes them on Advanced, along with scheduled bonus points campaigns, loyalty challenges, points on product pages and 130+ language translations. Neither the add-on nor Advanced has a printed price, so the cost of a VIP program on LoyaltyLion is a sales conversation.
For a store at 2,500 orders that wants VIP tiers, the comparison is Smile Growth against at least $399 on LoyaltyLion Classic before the VIP add-on is priced. If tiered rewards are the reason you are buying a loyalty app, Smile is the only one of the two that shows you the full price up front.
What LoyaltyLion does better
LoyaltyLion sells a managed launch. Every plan includes a branded rewards page built by its team, ready-to-use Klaviyo email flows built for you and a dedicated onboarding manager. On Smile, a dedicated launch plan and white-glove migration only arrive on the $999 Plus plan.
For a brand without a developer or a loyalty specialist, that setup is what the higher price buys. LoyaltyLion also connects to AI assistants such as Claude through MCP on every plan, offers Loyalty Pass for Apple and Google Wallet as an add-on, and adds AI campaign recommendations and automated loyalty flows on Plus.
The weaknesses are price visibility and reach. Advanced and Plus are custom quotes, the VIP add-on has no printed price, and Shopify POS covers a single location on Classic. Our LoyaltyLion review covers the plans in more detail.
What Smile.io does better
Smile is the self-serve choice with a printed price at almost every step. Shopify POS works on every plan including Free, Klaviyo email sending starts on the $15 Essential plan, and points embedded on product pages start on Standard. Smile is available on both Shopify and BigCommerce.
The Free plan is a real starting point for a new store: points, referrals, discount and free shipping rewards, full branding customization and multi-language support, up to 200 orders a month. API access and a front-end JavaScript SDK arrive on Plus, alongside priority support and quarterly program monitoring.
The weaknesses are the caps and the hands-off setup. Below Growth, each plan stops hard at its order limit, and you build the program yourself with live chat help rather than an onboarding manager. Our Smile.io review walks through each plan.
Which store should pick which
Pick Smile.io if you run a Shopify or BigCommerce store under 4,000 orders a month (see our Shopify vs BigCommerce comparison if the platform is still open) and want to set up points, referrals and VIP tiers yourself. It costs less at every printed volume, and Growth is the cheapest published route to VIP tiers among these two.
Pick LoyaltyLion if you want the vendor to build your rewards page and Klaviyo flows, sell in many languages, or expect to grow into AI-led campaigns and automated flows on its upper plans. Ask for a quote on Advanced before you buy the Classic VIP add-on, since the gap between them is not printed.
If you are still choosing between more vendors, our cheapest loyalty program software comparison adds Yotpo and Rivo, the best loyalty program software ranking covers features, and the Growave review covers a bundle that adds reviews and wishlists, and Yotpo pricing covers Yotpo's loyalty plans, a third option at this price level. For the email side of a loyalty program, see Klaviyo pricing and the Klaviyo review, and for the platform bill underneath, Shopify pricing.
How we compared them
We read Smile.io's and LoyaltyLion's pricing pages, including their plan cards, feature tables, FAQs and LoyaltyLion's order-volume price list, on November 4, 2026. Monthly and yearly totals apply the printed price for each order volume, add Smile's printed overage rate where a plan allows it, and multiply by twelve for a year; all are our arithmetic. Toolradar figures come from the Smile.io and LoyaltyLion profiles. Retailpresso runs no test lab, so this compares published plans and prices, not hands-on use.
FAQ
Is Smile.io or LoyaltyLion cheaper in 2026?
Smile.io is cheaper at every order volume where both print a price. At 500 orders a month Smile Essential costs $15 against $199 for LoyaltyLion Classic, and at 1,000 orders Smile Standard costs $79 against $249, as read on November 4, 2026.
Does Smile.io or LoyaltyLion have a free plan?
Smile.io has a free plan for up to 200 orders a month, with points, referrals and discount rewards. LoyaltyLion's pricing FAQ recommends its free plan to stores with 400 or fewer orders a month, though its plan cards start at Classic, and it offers a 14-day trial through the Shopify App Store.
Which plan includes VIP tiers?
Smile.io includes VIP tiers from its Growth plan, $199 a month for 2,500 orders. LoyaltyLion offers VIP tiers as an optional add-on on Classic and includes them on Advanced, and neither the add-on nor Advanced has a published price.
What happens if my store goes over its order limit?
On Smile.io, Growth charges $20 per 100 extra orders and Plus $5 per 100, while Free, Essential and Standard have no overage, so you move up a plan. LoyaltyLion prices by average monthly order volume and asks you to upgrade to the tier that fits your volume.
Does LoyaltyLion set up the program for you?
Yes. Every LoyaltyLion plan includes a branded rewards page built by its team, ready-to-use Klaviyo email flows and a dedicated onboarding manager. Smile.io includes a dedicated launch plan and migration only on its Plus plan.
Do Smile.io and LoyaltyLion work with Shopify POS?
Yes. Smile.io supports Shopify POS on every plan, including Free. LoyaltyLion supports Shopify POS for a single location on Classic and across multiple locations on Advanced and Plus.
Cite this: Retailpresso, "Smile.io vs LoyaltyLion (2026): Loyalty App Pricing and Which to Pick", November 2026.
Some offers on this page may be paid placements or contain affiliate links.
More Retailpresso reviews
Buyer guides and software reviews, with prices read from each vendor's own pricing page.
Browse all reviews