Loop Returns vs Redo (2026): Monthly Fee or Shopper-Paid Coverage?
Loop Returns vs Redo in 2026: Redo's portal is free and shoppers fund labels, Loop's paid plan starts at $340 a month on an annual contract. Read Nov 2026.

Redo costs a Shopify store less in software: its returns portal is free, and shoppers fund return labels through a coverage fee at checkout. Loop's paid Returns plan starts at $340 a month on an annual contract. Loop also has a shopper-funded option, Checkout+, but only for brands with 5,000 or more orders a year. Prices read on Loop's pricing page and Redo's pricing page on 4 November 2026.
So the real question is not which app is cheaper, it is who you want paying for returns. On Redo the shopper pays and the merchant pays nothing for the portal. On Loop the merchant either pays a monthly fee or qualifies for the same shopper-paid model under Loop's rules. A small store that misses Loop's volume bar has only one Loop option, and it is the expensive one.
Toolradar data: Toolradar, the software directory we run, evaluated 7 tools for its returns management ranking, updated 4 November 2026, and 3 of the 6 it ranks have a free plan. Loop Returns is one of them through Checkout+; Redo is not yet in Toolradar's catalog.
Loop vs Redo at a glance
| Loop Returns | Redo | |
|---|---|---|
| Free option | Checkout+, for brands with 5,000+ orders a year; Loop says not every merchant qualifies | Returns portal listed as free on the pricing page |
| Paid option | Returns plan from $340 a month, up to 1,000 returns | No paid returns plan; returns AI agents are custom priced |
| Who funds return labels | Merchant on the Returns plan; shopper fee on Checkout+ | Shopper coverage fee at checkout; merchant on refunds it chooses not to cover |
| Who sets the shopper fee | Merchant, at or above a floor price Loop sets | Redo, per store, from return rate and average label cost |
| Contract | Annual on the Returns plan, 6% increase at each renewal | No fixed term; the terms run while you use the service |
| Order tracking | Starter $99 a month for up to 2,000 shipments | $0.08 per tracked order |
| Best for | Brands that want fixed pricing and exchange tooling at volume | Stores that want returns software at $0 and accept a checkout fee |
Both platforms sell exchange-first features: Loop's Shop Now, Instant Exchange and Bonus Credit come with both of its returns plans, and Redo offers instant exchanges, bonus store credit and AI exchange suggestions. The difference that moves money is the billing model, so the rest of this page prices that.
How does each platform make money?
Loop charges merchants, Redo charges shoppers. That one line explains most of the comparison, and each has a catch worth reading.
Loop's Returns plan is a subscription. The plan card lists up to 1,000 returns, Shop Now, Instant Exchange, Bonus Credit and fraud prevention for a starting fee of $340 a month, billed on the returns submitted in each calendar month. Return labels are not on that list. Loop's free Checkout+ plan, by contrast, lists returns software plus US and Canada domestic return labels, Return Bars drop-offs and advanced features, paid for by a fee shoppers choose at checkout.
Redo has no subscription for returns. Shoppers who tick the Redo option at checkout pay a coverage fee, the money reaches you in your Shopify payout, and Redo invoices you for the same amount every two weeks. Its invoice guide calls this a pass-through charge that should not be booked as revenue, and says that when coverage is bought, Redo pays for every return label on that order, including labels for later exchanges.
What does each one cost a store below 5,000 orders a year?
For a store under Loop's Checkout+ bar, Loop costs at least $4,080 a year and Redo costs $0 in software. The bar works out to about 417 orders a month, and Loop says eligibility also depends on return volume, so some larger stores land on the paid plan too.
At 400 orders a month, Loop's starting fee spreads to $0.85 per order shipped. Spread over returns instead, it depends on how many come back:
| Returns per month | Loop Returns plan per return | Redo portal per return |
|---|---|---|
| 100 | $3.40 | $0 software; shopper-funded label |
| 500 | $0.68 | $0 software; shopper-funded label |
| 1,000 | $0.34 | $0 software; shopper-funded label |
Our arithmetic on Loop's printed starting price. Postage is a separate cost on Loop's paid plan, while on Redo the label comes out of coverage whenever the shopper bought it. A store doing 100 returns a month pays ten times more per return on Loop than one using the full allowance, which is why Loop's paid plan makes most sense near its 1,000-return ceiling.
What does the shopper pay on Redo?
Redo does not publish one coverage price, because it computes the fee for each store. Its coverage price article names two inputs, your return rate and your average label cost, so heavier parcels, longer shipping distances and more returns all push the fee up. Redo's sample return policy text uses $1.98 as its example.
At that example fee, every 1,000 shoppers who opt in hand $1,980 to Redo for labels, our arithmetic. That money is the cost of your returns program; it sits on the customer's receipt instead of your P&L. Shoppers who skip coverage can still return items but pay for the label themselves.
There is one setting that changes the shopper's experience a lot. Redo says most merchants limit free coverage to exchanges and store credit, so a covered shopper who wants a cash refund is still charged for the label. That keeps money in the store but can surprise a customer who paid for "free returns". Write the rule plainly in your return policy before switching it on.
What does the shopper pay on Loop Checkout+?
Loop sets a minimum and lets you charge more. Its terms of service, last updated 3 March 2026, say a Checkout+ merchant must charge at least Loop's floor price for the purchase fee and the handling fee, and may charge above it but not below. Loop can adjust those floors once every two weeks with seven days' notice.
Loop prints no floor price. Its Checkout+ page calculator assumes a $2.98 fee at checkout and a $10 fee at return, and says your own numbers depend on return rates and shipping costs. At that $2.98 assumption, 1,000 opted-in orders put $2,980 into the program, our arithmetic.
Loop's pitch for the model is volume: the same page claims up to 87% of shoppers opt in and that the fees can cover your return shipping in full. Those are Loop's own figures, not a benchmark, but they explain why Checkout+ is gated. The model only funds labels when far more shoppers pay than return.
Round 1: software cost. Redo wins
Redo lists its returns portal, claims portal and warranties as free, with white-glove onboarding included. Loop matches that only through Checkout+, and only when your volume qualifies. For the store under the bar, the choice is $0 against Loop's paid plan, which settles this round.
Free still has fine print. Redo's invoice guide lists Redo fee lines that can appear on an account, among them a per-return software fee, a POS per-return fee, a return receiving and processing fee for its returns centers, a fraud prevention software fee, an implementation fee and a card processing fee. The guide prints no amounts, so ask which apply to you in writing. Our Redo review walks through the rest of Redo's product prices.
Round 2: pricing control. Loop wins
On Checkout+, you set the shopper fee at or above Loop's floor, and on the Returns plan you know your fee for the year. Redo's merchant terms, last updated 15 August 2025, say Redo determines coverage pricing "at our sole and absolute discretion", may base changes on your return rate, product weight and label prices, and will try to give 5 days' notice of material increases.
For a brand that prices carefully at checkout, that matters. A rising return rate on Redo shows up as a higher fee in front of your customers, set by someone else. On Loop the same rise lands on you, either as a tier change or a smaller margin on your own fee, but you decide how much of it the shopper sees.
Round 3: commitment. Redo wins
Loop's pricing FAQ says its plans require an annual contract, except the shopper-funded Offset Free option and stand-alone order tracking, which can run month to month. For a store on the paid plan, the terms add three costs that the plan card does not show:
- 6% a year. An annual increase of 6% applies at the end of each term, so the starting plan runs $4,324.80 in year two and $4,584.29 in year three, $12,989.09 over three years, our arithmetic.
- 60 days' notice. Contracts renew unless you give written notice at least 60 days before the term ends.
- 2.9% on cards. Paying by credit card adds a 2.9% fee, $9.86 a month on the starting plan; ACH from a US bank account avoids it.
Redo's terms have no fixed term: they last as long as you use the service and end when you stop. The flip side is that Redo may end or change the service at any time, so keep your return policy portable either way. Our Loop Returns pricing guide covers Loop's volume tiers and its 2026 plan change in detail.
Round 4: tracking. Depends on volume
Loop sells order tracking separately, from $99 a month on Starter for brands shipping up to 2,000 items a month, $189 on Premium and a custom price on Plus, with 10% off when bundled with returns on an annual contract. Redo charges $0.08 per tracked order.
The break-even sits at about 1,237 tracked orders a month, our arithmetic. Below that, Redo's per-order rate is cheaper; at 2,000 orders it comes to $160 a month against Loop's $99. Tracking pages also absorb "where is my order" tickets, which our Gorgias pricing guide prices per ticket.
Round 5: international and label coverage. Loop wins narrowly
Loop's Checkout+ includes US and Canada domestic labels, and both Loop plans list cross-border returns. Redo's merchant terms describe its label help as labels back to your designated location in the United States, and Redo sells international returns as a separate product with its own settings, including the option to exclude international shoppers from the checkout opt-in.
A US-only store will not notice the difference, so it should decide on price. A store with a meaningful Canadian or cross-border customer base should ask each vendor, in writing, how those returns are funded before choosing.
Who should pick Redo
- Stores below Loop's Checkout+ bar. Loop's only option for them is the paid Returns plan, while Redo's portal costs nothing in software and the shopper funds the label.
- Brands comfortable with a checkout fee. The model works when your customers accept a small add-on in exchange for free returns.
- Teams that want no annual contract. Redo's merchant terms have no fixed term and no renewal deadline to diary.
Read the Redo review for the full product, including claims, package protection and Redo's per-use prices for email, support and checkout tools.
Who should pick Loop
- Brands near the plan's return ceiling that want a fixed bill. At full use the Returns plan costs $0.34 per return, and no customer ever sees a fee at checkout.
- High-volume brands that qualify for Checkout+. You get the shopper-funded model while setting the fee yourself above Loop's floor.
- Stores with Canadian or cross-border returns. Checkout+ labels cover the US and Canada, and cross-border returns are listed on both plans.
If neither fits, our best returns management software ranking compares Loop with ReturnGO, AfterShip and others, and the AfterShip review covers a returns and tracking suite with its own pricing. For context on how many orders come back, see our ecommerce returns statistics.
The rest of the post-purchase stack
Returns are one line in a store's app bill. The Shopify pricing guide shows the platform fees underneath, the best shipping software ranking covers outbound labels, and the best order management systems list covers stores that route returns across warehouses. The best free Shopify apps and best Shopify apps lists show where both returns tools sit next to the rest.
How we built this page
We read Loop's pricing page, Checkout+ page and terms of service, and Redo's pricing page, returns product page, merchant terms and help center articles on coverage pricing, billing and invoices, all on 4 November 2026. Per-return, per-order, yearly and tracking break-even figures are our arithmetic on those printed prices, not vendor quotes; quoted prices can differ. Shopper fee examples are each vendor's own published examples, not prices your store will get. Toolradar's figures come from its returns management ranking, updated 4 November 2026.
FAQ
Is Redo cheaper than Loop Returns?
For software, yes. Redo's returns portal is free and shoppers fund return labels with a coverage fee at checkout. Loop's Returns plan starts at $340 a month on an annual contract, and its free Checkout+ plan is limited to brands with 5,000 or more orders a year, per both pricing pages on 4 November 2026.
How much does Redo coverage cost the shopper?
Redo sets the fee per store from your return rate and average label cost, so there is no single list price. Its sample return policy text uses $1.98 as the example. Shoppers who skip coverage can still return items but pay for the return label.
Is Loop Returns free?
Loop's Checkout+ plan is free to the merchant because shoppers pay a fee at checkout for a free return later. Loop says it is for brands with 5,000 or more orders a year and that not every merchant qualifies. Everyone else starts on the paid Returns plan, at $4,080 a year at the starting price by our arithmetic.
Does Loop or Redo require a contract?
Loop's Returns plan requires an annual contract that renews automatically unless you give 60 days' written notice, with a 6% increase at each renewal. Redo's merchant terms have no fixed term and last as long as you use the service.
Who pays for return labels on Redo?
When a shopper buys coverage, Redo pays for every return label on that order, funded by the coverage fee. Many merchants limit free coverage to exchanges and store credit, so shoppers asking for a cash refund pay for the label. Merchants pay for labels they choose to cover, such as damaged or wrong items.
Which is cheaper for order tracking, Loop or Redo?
Redo charges $0.08 per tracked order and Loop's Starter tracking plan costs $99 a month for up to 2,000 shipments. Redo is cheaper below about 1,237 orders a month and Loop is cheaper above it, our arithmetic on prices read 4 November 2026.
Cite this: Retailpresso, "Loop Returns vs Redo (2026): Monthly Fee or Shopper-Paid Coverage?", November 2026.
Some offers on this page may be paid placements or contain affiliate links.
More Retailpresso reviews
Buyer guides and software reviews, with prices read from each vendor's own pricing page.
Browse all reviews